Rural Alberta Advantage dinner plate by Erin Nicholson
Music

Beginning of the year-ends
The pros and cons of year-end music lists

Do music best-of lists have any redeeming qualities?

Heading into the season of lists, we're about to find out. In the meantime...

The positives of music year-end lists:

  • uncovering the overlooked albums;
  • offering a review of the year in music;
  • as this post demonstrates, lists are easy to read. 

The negatives:

  • reducing a years' worth of music to 10 albums, one of which is usually taken by Radiohead;
  • futile attempts at comprehensiveness, like including one hip hop album however undeserving;
  • obscure picks for no other reason than obscurity;
  • surface music criticism.

But one list that usually floats above the fray is local blog Chromewaves' top 10. This year's, released Friday, was no different. And it even added another point to the plus side: interesting artwork, in this case musical dinner plates.

Take a look.

Dec 16, 2008 at 12:13 AM
Copyright 2010 NOW Communications
Comments
Posted by Goon on 12/20/2008, 01:17 AM
"The negatives: obscure picks for no other reason than obscurity"

Obviously Tim Perlich didn't write this article, otherwise this line certainly wouldn't appear.

Posted by The Fall of Troy on 12/31/2008, 05:58 PM
NOW Magazine has now prominently featured the decorative dinnerware featuring the Rural Alberta Advantage. Cromewaves has picked Hometowns for its year-end list. How about a record review? Hometowns is easily my favorite album of the year. This band needs to get some major media exposure.

Post a comment :

All comments are reviewed. HTML links are not allowed.

Leave this field empty
NOW DAILY
TUESDAY | FEB | 09 | 2010

NOW Magazine on Facebook