Protesters are angry that Canada has no policy prohibiting charities like the Jewish National Fund from funding projects on West Bank.
Photo By Andrew Serba
News

Jewish charity targeted
Demonstrators say JNF fundraising an obstacle to Middle East peace

Two hundred activists braved winter’s blasts December 2 and took to the sidewalk in front of the Sheraton Hotel on Queen to protest the Jewish National Fund’s annual gala.

The dinner honouring local phil-antropist Miles S. Nadal was part of a $7 million fundraising effort to refurbish Israel’s Ayalon/Canada Park, which the JNF calls “a mosaic of heritage and nature providing people with the ultimate outdoor experience.”

But protestors from the 13 different groups present on this wet and snowy night had a different take: they described the 1,000-acre nature spread as an obstacle to future peace between Israelis and Palestinians.

Besides the fact that the park arguably extends into the West Bank, the pines of the green space tower over land that was once the Palestinian villages of Imwas and Yalu. The two, plus Beit Nuba, which is adjacent to the park, were razed by Israel in the 1967 war.

Chanting and carrying pictures of the destroyed villages, speakers charged that the Canadian government was subsidizing the displacement of people via charitable tax deductions.

Reena Katz, a member of the Coalition Against Israeli Apartheid, told the crowd, “The JNF is fundraising to support the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian villages in the West Bank” – actions that our tax money should not be supporting.

“The Canadian public has a right to know the truth behind Canada Park. They need to know that the JNF is helping to reinforce the status quo of Palestinian dispossession,” she said.

Khaled Mouammar, director of the Canadian Arab Federation, asked why the JNF was allowed to “continue business as usual” getting Canadian charitable tax deductions when the confiscation of land is illegal under international law and traumatizes the Palestinian collective memory.

How do the feds see the issue? When NOW calls the Canada Revenue Agency a few days after the demo, spokesperson Béatrice Fénelon explains that there is no clear public policy prohibiting charitable projects on the West Bank.

In the absence of such legislation, she says, “the CRA cannot treat the fact that such activities occur in the Occupied Territories as a barrier to their charitable status.”

NOW | December 20-27, 2007 | VOL 27 NO 16
Copyright 2009 NOW Communications
Comments
Posted by Smadar Carmon on 12/21/2007, 12:38 PM
Good article on a very important issue, thank you Dina for being there and NOW for publishing it.

Posted by Smadar Carmon on 12/21/2007, 12:43 PM
Good article on a very important issue, thank you Dina for being there and NOW for publishing it.

Posted by Elizabeth Block on 12/21/2007, 02:51 PM
Thanks for covering our demo. Canadians should know what our tax money is being used for. Then maybe we won't have to ask why do they hate us.

Posted by jon david on 12/22/2007, 10:58 PM
how can you say israel does not have a right to exist? better a park then another spot to fire rockets into israel. the jnf is a world leader in environmental research and issues.

Posted by Monserrat Glasman on 12/25/2007, 09:02 AM
Well said Jon David. I have an idea, why don't protesters put their energy making sure that the aid money going to Palestine authorities actually gets to the people, instead of worrying about a park. Also, it is about time that NOW magazine also informs Torontonians about the fact that the disputed territories gained in 1967 are secured by Israel in order to ensure their safety.

Posted by r on 12/26/2007, 12:12 PM
Looks like there are a lot of misinformed and misguided protestors from every walk of life.

Posted by B. Katz on 01/13/2008, 07:19 PM
The JNF is now merely another tool used by Israel to steal Palestinian land. They are *not* the leading environmentalists in Israel. The article said nothing about "Israel's right to exist" Mr. David. But Israel's repeated violations of international law and the Geneva conventions (look them up Mr. Glasman) will ultimately cause it to fail as a modern democratic state.

Post a comment :

All comments are reviewed.


NEWS POLL